
Adrien Rabiot is not happy with referee Massa. And not with the yellow card that Genoa's Marcandalli received. The interference in midfield, during a counterattack, was what angered him. But what happened next made him explode. After the match, former referee Calvarese defended the interpretation and the yellow card given by the referee. The Milan midfielder responded publicly: "By constantly lying you will not progress."
The former referee had assessed the referee's decision as correct, or at least defensible, referring to the gray area and VAR. A serious statement, because it shifts the discussion from the single episode on the field to the credibility of the referees' explanations.
DOGSO and the yellow card for Marcandalli
Marcandalli brings down Rabiot. Massa issues a yellow card. Rabiot asks for a red card. According to him, it is a DOGSO, that is, a clear goal-scoring opportunity being obstructed. Calvarese, in his video, talks about a distance of 65 meters and a position shifted to the side. But he does not talk about Cisse. However, the IFAB regulation on DOGSO provides that the position of the other attackers must also be assessed. Cisse was in the center, was free and was heading towards the goal. This is the element missing in Calvarese's video.
Below that video, Rabiot directly engages in the discussion. He doesn't write "it was a red card." He writes that the problem is another. That you can be wrong, but you can't say you weren't wrong. That, by defending everything at all costs, "it's Italian football that suffers the consequences." Initially it was a discussion about a foul. Now it's a discussion about those who explain fouls.

Calvarese: "If the red card had been given, VAR would not have intervened"
Calvarese responds in this way. He doesn't say: I'm right. But he adjusts his stance somewhat. "Let's say from the start that it's a complex episode, we're in the grey area." Then he adds the sentence that really matters: "If referee Massa had shown the red card, VAR wouldn't have intervened."
What did he want to explain? That the yellow card issued to Massa does not constitute an absolute truth, but was a choice made within a margin of appreciation provided for by the regulations. So, it is not a serious, obvious or clearly unfair mistake. It is no longer a question of a yellow or red card. It is a question of lying or a grey area.
Lie or gray area? This is where the debate began.
If VAR had also accepted the red card, why should the yellow card be defended as if it were the only right decision? This is the question that Rabiot leaves open. He says: if you are wrong, admit it. If you continue to say that everything is right, you cannot move forward like this. It is an accusation that goes beyond the technical assessment of a single episode. And it is no longer a question of the foul. It is a question of the way fouls are explained.