
A handball in the Fiorentina area, Juventus protests and a penalty that, according to the referee Luca Marelli, should have been awarded. This is the most controversial episode of the 2-2 draw at the “Franchi”, where in the 79th minute Joao Mario intercepted the ball with his left arm, which was clearly open in relation to his body. Referee Andrea Colombo allowed the game to continue and VAR did not call him to review the episode on the monitor.
A decision that the former referee opposed without hesitation during the analysis of the video on DAZN: "There is no doubt that it is punishable. The arm is too wide, the VAR should have called the referee." But why, according to the regulations, should this contact be punished?
Joao Mario's handball: what happened in the 79th minute
The episode occurred at the end of the match, when the score was 2-2. Juventus took the ball into the Fiorentina area, the home defense tried to clear it and the ball, after a bounce on the field, ended up on the left wing of Joao Mario. The point of contact was below the elbow, while the Portuguese's arm was open in relation to the silhouette of the body.
The black and white players, starting with Kolo Muani, immediately protested. Luciano Spalletti also reacted angrily from the bench. Colombo, however, did not award a penalty, while from the VAR room, where Aleandro Di Paolo and Francesco Meraviglia worked, no request came for a review of the episode on the monitor. It is precisely the position of the winger that makes the decision questionable. Marelli, analyzing the footage on DAZN, argued that the contact was clearly punishable and that VAR should have intervened, to give the referee the opportunity to review the action.
https://t.co/u0pDEImfvF
— pjvideos4 (@pjvideos4) November 8, 2026
Why Joao Mario's open arm is punishable by regulation
IFAB Law 12 does not automatically consider any contact between the ball and the arm to be a foul. However, it does provide for the punishment of a player who touches the ball with an arm whose position unnaturally increases the space occupied by the body, when this position is not justified by the movement performed in that specific situation.
So, the goal is not a necessary condition for awarding a penalty. Nor does the fact that the ball comes after a bounce on the field automatically make the contact legal. The position of the limb, the movement of the defender and whether the latter is occupying unjustified space with his arm must be assessed.
According to the motion expert Marelli, this is exactly what happens in Joao Mario's action: the left arm is too far from the body and the contact cannot be considered legal. There is also the issue of the lack of VAR intervention. The IFAB protocol allows for the correction of a clear and obvious error by the referee in decisions related to penalties. In a subjective episode, such as a handball due to increased body volume, the appropriate procedure is normally a review on the monitor, leaving the final decision to the main referee.
In Florence, this review did not take place. The communications between referee Colombo and the VAR room have not been made public, so it is not possible to determine what assessments were made during the review. However, the position of former referee Marelli remains firm: the position of Joao Mario's arm made the contact punishable and the VAR should have called the referee.
