
Kylian Mbappé did not play against Italy due to injury. He stood on the bench and smiled. He was even slightly involved during the national anthems. He seemed uninterested, as if he were a student on the last day of school, before the bell rang for the end of class. He was there, just two meters from his teammates, who were on the pitch conceding Italy's goals in the Nations League match. Next to him was Marcus Thuram, equally relaxed. Both were holding their phones in their hands and having fun. That was enough: a few seconds of television footage caused a storm of reactions in France. Because Mbappé had also been talked about on the eve of the match, due to his disagreements with Zidane. Because Mbappé is not just a footballer, but the captain of the team. And he remains that way even when he is not playing. Because, if after a match lost in that way (3-1, after a subpar second half), you go to the locker room, change your clothes and leave immediately, it only reinforces that impression.
Rothen doesn't criticize her for her smile, but for what it represents.
Jerome Rothen, at RMC, did not say that “he shouldn’t have laughed”. He pointed out something more serious: “For the captain not to worry at all, for him to laugh while France concedes three goals to Italy… It’s shocking”. The former footballer, now a pundit, is right to raise this issue, but the danger lies in reducing everything to just a smile, as this can be misleading. A photograph or a short television clip does not tell you why Mbappé is laughing. Maybe Thuram showed him a meme or something else. It could happen. The point, however, is this: when you wear the captain’s armband, you have a responsibility not only when you play, but also when you follow the match from the sidelines.

Being the best doesn't mean being a reference point in the locker room.
And this is where the controversy raised by Rothen becomes interesting. Mbappé is undoubtedly a very strong footballer, a champion who can decide the fate of a match with an extraordinary action. But that does not automatically make you a point of reference inside the locker room. They are two different things, it is the difference between authority and authority earned through respect. The first is also given by goals. The second you have to earn when you do not score.
At the San Siro, Mbappé was not forced to sing the national anthem. Rothen himself has stressed this: “That’s not the problem. In France, many players don’t sing it.” And that doesn’t mean you don’t respect your country, or that you’re more patriotic if you sing it out loud. It also didn’t mean he had to appear angry in front of the cameras to show everyone he was enjoying the game. In short, he didn’t have to pretend. He just had to understand one simple thing: even in his tracksuit, on the bench, with his phone in his hand, you represent France. You have to maintain a certain demeanor, because you’re a symbol. And you can’t be caught laughing when your team is playing badly, struggling or, worse yet, losing. Not because it’s forbidden. But because it’s unwise to behave like that in front of 70,000 people and twenty cameras. That’s it.

France doesn't just want goals, they also want him to be present.
France has chosen Mbappé as captain because he represents the present and the future. But fame does not automatically translate into authority. And talent does not make you a leader just because you are the best in the group. “You have to have a certain demeanor,” Rothen continues. “That is part of the respect for your country. In Italy, in San Siro, Kylian Mbappé knows that he will be the focus of the cameras. For the captain to take out his phone during the match, not care about anything and laugh while France concedes three goals to Italy… Yes, it is shocking!”
When France wins, it's easy to be its symbol and to come forward to represent it. When France loses at the Meazza, it shows whether you're really there. And it's not about stopping the smiles, it's about presence and responsibility.
🇫🇷💥 Rothen: "Kylian Mbappé sait qu'il va être filmed. Que le capitaine prenne son téléphone pendant le match, qu'il s'en foute autant, qu'il rigole alors que la France en prend trois face à l'Italie... Oui, c'est choquant!" https://t.co/0k7gdyH0Yi
— Rothen s'enflamme (@Rothensenflamme) November 17, 2026