Flash

AMA fines against political shows raise alarm over violation of freedom of expression

Lapsi.al 2026-11-09 14:47:00
AMA Chairwoman, Armela Krasniqi speaking during a conference organized by the Audiovisual Media Authority, | Photo: LSA

Journalist Blendi Fevziu began his show “Opinion” on a note of protest on Thursday evening. Wearing a uniform with the words “AMA Police,” Fevziu mocked the effect of a fine imposed by the Audiovisual Media Authority for “inappropriate language content.”

"I'm not complaining about the fine, but I'm complaining that after 30 years in this studio... they want to turn my normal attire into that of an AMA police officer," Fevziu declared.

"I should no longer be the journalist leading a debate between two balanced parties or on a topic that has different points of view, but I should be the policeman standing here to check and certify every word that every guest says, to reprimand him if it is inappropriate," he added.

The fine addressed to the show "Opinon" is related to the debate on October 22 on anti-government protests, where journalist Armand Shkullaku declared, among other things, that: "We don't know how many days Rama will stay in power, that Rama will eventually retreat, he has crossed the red line, he has deprived himself of the opportunity for negotiations."

For the host of the show that is broadcast live every evening, this is a ridiculous measure, intended to dictate to the guests what to say or to censor them.

The "Opinion" show is not the only one.

In the days of violent clashes during student protests, a number of political shows on other screens have faced similar fines from the AMA, alleging the show featured violent images or the use of hate speech, incitement or justification of violence by panelists.

Among those fined are the show "Ora e Betit" on Ora News TV, "Kafe Shqeto" on Syri TV, or Të Paeksozuarit on Vizion Plus.

Journalist Beti Njuma's show "Ora e Betit" was fined 100 thousand lekë, among other things, arguing that the program's host had not reacted to condemn these positions nor had she distanced herself from them, thus violating the rules of ethics, public morality and the Broadcasting Code that strictly prohibit content that incites violence or discrimination.

Journalist Beti Njuma told BIRN that this campaign is bringing back “Bolshevik methods of punishment for critical media and protesters.”

"I am speechless by this behavior of the AMA leader, which instead of a regulatory institution resembles the Ministry of Truth in Orwell's 1984, which seeks to control and censor even what people think," said Njuma in protest.

Ndërkohë, moderatori Flavio Qarri i Syri TV deklaroi publikisht se ishte gjobitur pasi kishte transmetuar pamjet e shoqërimit nga policia të një protestuesi me këmbë të thyer.

AMA nuk komentoi deri në publikimin e këtij shkrimi nëse shtimi i masave administrative ndaj emisioneve të debatit lidhej me protestat e fundit dhe klimën e tensionuar politike në vend dhe nëse interpretimet ligjore mund krijonin efekt censurues dhe frikësues për mediat.

‘Zinxhir ndëshkimesh’ për protestat

Shoqatat në mbrojtje të gazetarëve dhe ekspertë të medias i shohin me shqetësim sanksionet  ndëshkuese të AMA-s ndaj gazetarëve, të cilat vijnë në të njëjtën kohë me masa të tjera represive ndaj tubimeve dhe protestuesve.

Sipas tyre, AMA po përdor formulimet ligjore për të tentuar censurë apo vetëcensurë si ndaj mediave kritike, ashtu edhe ndaj gazetarëve.

Asociacioni i Gazetarëve të Shqipërisë, AGSH, kërkoi të enjten që AMA të tregojë vetëpërmbajtje në vendosjen e sanksioneve ndaj mediave dhe të respektojë standardet evropiane të lirisë së shprehjes, duke konsideruar se gjobat janë vendosur në rrethana që “ngrenë pikëpyetje mbi proporcionalitetin e ndërhyrjeve administrative dhe respektimin e lirisë së shprehjes”.

“Liria e shprehjes, e garantuar nga neni 10 i Konventës Evropiane për të Drejtat e Njeriut, nuk mbron vetëm informacionet dhe opinionet që priten pozitivisht, por edhe ato që mund të fyejnë, tronditin ose shqetësojnë shtetin apo një pjesë të shoqërisë,” thuhet në deklaratën e AGSH-së.

Edhe kryetarja e Komisionit Parlamentar për të Drejtat e Njeriut dhe Mediat, Jorida Tabaku, e konsideroi shqetësuese sjelljen e AMA-s, duke e cilësuar institucionin si “policia e mendimit në mashën e sistemit”. Ndërkohë, deputetët e Partisë Demokratike në Komisionin për të Drejtat e Njeriut dhe Mjetet e Informimit Publik njoftuan se kishin kërkuar për raportim mbi këtë çështje drejtoreshën e AMA.

I pyetur nga BIRN, gazetari Lutfi Dervishi e sheh sjelljen e AMA-s si pjesë të një fushate më të gjerë kundër protestave antiqeveritare.

“Po krijohet përshtypja e një zinxhiri ndëshkimesh: gjoba për ata që protestojnë, gjoba për televizionet që transmetojnë protestat dhe presion mbi gazetarët që i diskutojnë ato. Nëse kjo logjikë vazhdon, nuk do të ishte çudi që një ditë të diskutohej edhe gjoba për shikuesit që ndjekin televizionin e ‘gabuar’,” ironizoi Dervishi.

Ndërsa thekson se nxitja e dhunës është e papranueshme dhe media ka përgjegjësinë që të mos shndërrohet në platformë për kërcënime, Dervishi bën një dallim thelbësor mes një televizioni që promovon dhunë dhe një televizioni, ku një i ftuar përdor gjuhë të papranueshme gjatë një transmetimi të drejtpërdrejtë – ku gazetari nuk mund të konsiderohet automatikisht përgjegjës.

“In a period of ongoing protests, clashes with the police and political tensions, when the government is tightening legislation on gatherings and increasing sanctions against protesters, the media regulatory authority “appears to have launched a punitive campaign against television stations that broadcast these developments live,” he stressed.

For communication professor Erlis Çela, AMA's latest practice marks a significant change from the way the institution has previously acted towards televised political debates.

He raises the concern that increasing punitive measures during times of protests could create the perception of political use of the institution and directly impact the limits of freedom of expression.

“When punitive intervention becomes more intense and becomes the norm, a fertile ground for censorship and self-censorship is created,” says Çela.

Harsh criticism of the government, provocative expressions or statements that disturb the government cannot be automatically classified as incitement to violence, Çela emphasizes, considering this a dangerous precedent for editorial freedom.

He warns that the main risk is not only related to concrete fines, but to the creation of a practice where editorial offices start making editorial decisions by anticipating the punitive reaction of the regulatory authority. For this reason, Çela demands that the AMA's approach be publicly opposed and that the responsible parliamentary committee hold accountable for the way the institution is exercising its powers.

Dervishi also raises some questions about whether the AMA has applied the same standards in previous cases, regardless of the content and authors of the statements.

"If the standard becomes stricter only when protests put the government in difficulty, then the problem is no longer just administrative, but directly affects the credibility and independence of the regulator," he concludes./ Reporter.al

Të këshilluara

Doctors in Albania, 53% of the EU average

Albania continues to have one of the lowest levels of doctors relative to population in the Western Balkans, remaining far below the European Union average. Ac...

10:44

ide

Andi Bushati: Parody of the taxation of the rich by their prime minister

Regardless of the rhetoric, there can be no illusion that Edi Rama has joined the global trend to reduce inequalities. Because the debate that is raging today is essentially concerned that their deepening is leading to the destruction of democracy. While in our country the opposite is happening. It is the will to destroy democracy that is producing more inequality.

13:31 Andi Bushati

Andi Bushati: Edi Rama is behind the money seized in Germany

Payments to the former head of SHISH from rigged tenders of ANA prove the strange mania to compromise with the state's money and its officials. It doesn't matter that Vlora Hyseni was appointed by Rama himself, it didn't matter that she was considered a blind loyalist, without being corrupt she couldn't be called a devoted servant

15:14 Andi Bushati

MOTI TIRANA

20°c

KËMBIMI EURO

90.02

aktuale

Ndiqe Lapsin edhe në

Me interes nga publiku

Me sytë katër

PAPARAZZI